Stephan,
This is an excellent response, and well written. I remember that we
discussed this in one of my history classes, and it never hurts to hear it
again.
Anita
>From: "Stephan A. Schwartz" <[log in to unmask]>
>Reply-To: Discussion of research and writing about Virginia history
> <[log in to unmask]>
>To: [log in to unmask]
>Subject: Re: Islamic Slavery (was Re: Slavery and immoral stance, etc.)
>Date: Thu, 14 Jun 2007 16:54:21 -0400
>
>Let me suggest that the association of slavery with Southern American
>history (including Virginia) stems from the unique disposition and
>cultural affect of the American colonial and post independence periods,
>which made possible a coherent industrial agricultural system built around
>cotton and tobacco. One which required large numbers of workers, in the
>absence of the machinery which would ultimately displace this approach to
>agri-business. That these workers were African, as opposed to indentured
>Irish, say, I would propose is a product of both historical synchronicity:
>the rise of exploration and the place of slavery at the time, in the
>Africa the explorers discovered, and the evolutionary development that
>produced a resistance to Malaria in Africans, particularly west Africans
>-- and which also was the source of this same population's problems with
>sickle cell trait -- about 2 million Americans have sickle cell trait.
>About 1 in 12 African Americans has sickle cell trait.
>
>-- Stephan
>
>On 14 Jun 2007, at 16:29, Anita Wills wrote:
>
>>It is interesting that you now lay the association of Islam with slavery
>>in my lap. I did not make that association, which is why I posed the
>>question. We are supposed to be discussing Virginia history in general
>>and American history in particular. I was simply attempting to bring the
>>discussion back to Virginia History. BTW I was not posing the question to
>>anyway in particular, so please do not take offense.
>>
>>However, thank you for at least attempting to answer the question.
>>
>>Anita
>>
>>
>>>From: David Kiracofe <[log in to unmask]>
>>>Reply-To: Discussion of research and writing about Virginia history
>>> <[log in to unmask]>
>>>To: [log in to unmask]
>>>Subject: Re: Islamic Slavery (was Re: Slavery and immoral stance, etc.)
>>>Date: Thu, 14 Jun 2007 15:21:55 -0400
>>>
>>>I'm a bit put off with your association of Islam, which is a cultural
>>>and religious system, with the institution of slavery as practiced in
>>>its various locales. Yes, Islamic law validated the holding of slaves,
>>>but so did Christianity and numerous other faiths. But surely the
>>>association of the buying and selling of people should be with the
>>>people who did the buying and selling and not their presumed belief
>>>systems. Neither the African Muslim seller (and not all sellers were in
>>>fact Muslims) nor the European Christian buyers were behaviing in ways
>>>that one would call specifically religious, rather they were engaged in
>>>a very secular economic activity.
>>>
>>>To get to your question though (I wouldn't want to be accused of evading
>>>it), Europeans began associating Africans with exploitable labor well
>>>before Columbus. The Portuguese who acquired the first African slaves
>>>(around 1440) did so from Muslim merchants in West Africa. The
>>>degradation of people who were so different from themselves validated
>>>Europeans' sense of occupying a higher place in the hierarchy of nature.
>>> Europeans were quick to exploit Native workers in the Americas as
>>>well. When desease and other problems with Native workers created
>>>shortages, the contacts with those West African merchants were already
>>>in place and ready to fill the need. Muslim merchants didn't create
>>>this worldview, their role was simply to make it concrete for Europeans.
>>>
>>>To jump ahead to Virginia, we can see that the English came to the new
>>>world with pre-existing social notions about the nature of the universe
>>>-- in which some were of higher order than others -- and economic ideas
>>>about the exploitation of the labor of lower orders, including both
>>>Native Americans and Africans as well as other Europeans. If Native
>>>American people resisted coerced labor, those who were prepared to be
>>>dominant were ready to turn to other "lower" people. In Virginia that
>>>meant principally the lower orders of English society and so there was
>>>the massive migration of lower class servants.
>>>
>>>One result of bringing over people from the English-speaking world was
>>>that the society of early Virginia was very fluid: one could serve one's
>>>time and then acquire freedom, and possibly land and status, and so move
>>>up from the lower ranks. As the colonial society matured, however,
>>>there was a desire to make a more fixed, less fluid, society (more like
>>>that of England where rank was very clearly delineated) and so there was
>>>a need to settle on a labor system where labor was unable to achieve
>>>freedom and its material and social benefits. Therefore we see the
>>>movement toward slavery and particularly African slavery. It wasn't
>>>all about race and yet race was so central to the practice of it as to
>>>make the distinction all but irrelevant.
>>>
>>>I know this is a very truncated history of the beginnings of slavery in
>>>Virginia, leaving out the perhaps anomalous experience of the first
>>>Africans brought to Jamestown, and further skipping past the
>>>developments in Virginia law pertaining to labor and race, but I will
>>>leave it there and if anyone wants to add, subtract or even just
>>>quibble, well, that's what we're all here for.
>>>
>>>David Kiracofe
>>>
>>>
>>>David Kiracofe
>>>History
>>>Tidewater Community College
>>>Chesapeake Campus
>>>1428 Cedar Road
>>>Chesapeake, Virginia 23322
>>>757-822-5136
>>> >>> Anita Wills <[log in to unmask]> 06/14/07 12:53 PM >>>
>>>My question is what did Islam have to do with Europeans enslaving
>>>Indians?
>>>No one seems to want to answer that.
>>
>>_________________________________________________________________
>>Get a preview of Live Earth, the hottest event this summer - only on MSN
>>http://liveearth.msn.com?source=msntaglineliveearthhm
_________________________________________________________________
Like puzzles? Play free games & earn great prizes. Play Clink now.
http://club.live.com/clink.aspx?icid=clink_hotmailtextlink2
|